Question: How are ISO, NSO and RSU equity awards taxed at exercise, vesting and sale?
ISO vs. NSO vs. RSU Taxes: Exercise, Vesting, AMT and Sale Rules
Incentive stock options, non-qualified options and restricted stock units each create income at a different moment and in a different character. Here is when each one hits your return, how the AMT adjustment works, and where employers report the amounts.
Tax Planning13 min read
By Joanny Ibarbia, EA · CAA

Quick answer
ISO exercise generally creates no regular taxable income but can increase income for AMT. An NSO without a readily determinable value at grant generally creates wages at exercise. An RSU usually creates wages at settlement, often on the vesting date. At sale, the tax basis determines the capital gain or loss.
Key points
- ISO exercise generally creates no regular taxable income but can create an AMT adjustment.
- An NSO without a readily determinable grant-date value generally creates wages at exercise equal to the share value less the price paid.
- An RSU generally creates wages at settlement. The vesting date and the delivery date can differ.
- A qualifying ISO sale generally requires both 1 year after stock transfer and 2 years after option grant.
- Form 1099-B basis can omit compensation already taxed as wages or be blank. Using a basis that is too low can overstate capital gain.
What is the difference between an ISO, an NSO, and an RSU?
The three awards differ in one thing that drives everything else: what you actually hold. An option is a right to buy shares at a fixed price you lock in on day one. A restricted stock unit is not an option at all. It is your employer's promise to deliver shares or cash under the terms of the award after the conditions are met, so there is nothing to buy and no exercise price to fund.
Options then split into two legal categories, and the line between them is stricter than most grant letters suggest. Statutory options are incentive stock options (ISOs) and options granted under employee stock purchase plans. To stay statutory you must be an employee of the granting company or a related company from the grant date through the point three months before you exercise (one year for an ISO if you are disabled), and the option must be nontransferable except at death. Fail either test and, in the words of the IRS, "your option is a nonstatutory stock option."[1] That single sentence is why departing employees who exercise late in a post-termination window so often get NSO treatment on an award they were told was an ISO. Employees at technology and SaaS startups routinely see all three instruments inside a single offer.
When does each award create taxable income?
An ISO generally creates no regular taxable income at grant or exercise, though the exercise can affect alternative minimum tax.[2][3] An NSO without an easily determined market value at grant generally creates compensation at exercise, equal to the market value of the stock received less the amount paid.[7] A stock-settled RSU generally creates compensation when vested shares are transferred. The grant can tie settlement to the vesting date or set a later delivery date.[10][12]
These differences affect how much basis belongs to the shares. An ISO usually starts with what the employee paid for regular tax, with a separate basis for AMT if there is an adjustment. For an NSO or stock-settled RSU, the compensation already included in income generally forms part of the regular tax basis.
| Award type | Taxed at grant | Taxed at exercise or vesting | Character of that income | Your basis in the shares afterward |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ISO | No | Generally no regular income at exercise, but an AMT adjustment can apply | None for regular tax in the exercise year | Price paid for regular tax. AMT basis reflects any applicable adjustment. |
| NSO | No, absent a readily determinable value at grant | Yes, at exercise | Ordinary wage income, shown in box 12 with code V | Exercise price plus the amount already taxed as wages |
| RSU | No | Yes, generally at settlement | Ordinary wage income | For shares, the value included as wages plus any amount paid |
How is an ISO taxed when you exercise it?
Exercising an ISO adds nothing to regular gross income, which is the whole point of the award.[2] It can create an alternative minimum tax adjustment. For AMT purposes the shares are treated as if no special rule applied, and once your rights turn transferable, or the substantial risk of forfeiture lapses, the amount by which market value exceeds the option price can increase income for AMT.[3]
Two consequences follow that option holders routinely miss. First, if the adjustment applies, it generally raises your AMT basis in the shares above your regular basis, which is why the IRS tells you to keep adequate records for both systems.[3] Second, the adjustment vanishes entirely when the shares are sold in the same tax year they were bought.[3] A same year sale and a long hold are therefore two different tax events, not two versions of one. The AMT exemption and the income level at which it phases out are set separately for each tax year, so an identical exercise can cost materially different amounts in two adjacent years. Sizing the exercise against that year's numbers is the real work, and our tax planning team models it before the exercise rather than at filing.

What holding period do ISO shares have to clear?
Two clocks run at the same time and you have to beat both of them. The IRS sets the test as holding "until the end of the later of the 1-year period after the stock was transferred to you or the 2-year period after the option was granted."[4] Clear both and the sale is a qualifying disposition and produces capital gain or loss. Sell a day short on either one and it is a disqualifying disposition. There is one narrow escape: you are still treated as meeting the test if you sold to comply with conflict of interest requirements.[4]
A disqualifying disposition is specific rather than punitive. On an arm’s-length sale at a gain, the ordinary income is the smaller of the actual gain or the difference between the share value at exercise and the option price. Any remaining gain is capital gain.[5] On an arm’s-length sale at a loss there is generally no ordinary income at all and the result is simply a capital loss.[5]
- The compensation piece belongs in wages: your employer reports it in box 1 of Form W-2, not on Schedule D.[5]
- If it never reaches your Form W-2, the IRS still expects it reported as wages for the year of the sale or other disposition.[5]
- Your basis for the capital piece is what you paid on exercise plus the amount reported as wages, so the two halves cannot be computed independently.[5]
- One sale can produce ordinary income and capital gain at once, which is why a single line on a brokerage statement rarely tells the whole story.[5]
- A disqualifying disposition in the same year as the exercise also removes the AMT adjustment for that year.[3]
When is Form 3921 due after an ISO exercise?
Form 3921 records an ISO share transfer, including the exercise price and the market value at exercise. The usual deadline to furnish the recipient statement is January 31 of the following year, moving to the next business day when it falls on a weekend or legal holiday.[6][13][14] For shares transferred in 2025, that meant February 2, 2026. For shares transferred in 2026, it is February 1, 2027.
The form gives a preparer the starting values for the exercise-year AMT analysis and for reviewing cost basis when the shares are sold. With restricted shares or later adjustments, the grant and transfer records can also matter. See individual tax return preparation.

How is a non-qualified stock option taxed?
An NSO is the simpler instrument and the more expensive one. Most nonstatutory options have no readily determinable value at grant, so nothing happens on the grant date; at exercise you include the market value of the shares received, less the amount you paid.[7] That spread is compensation rather than investment return, so it carries income tax withholding and payroll tax in the year you exercise, whether or not you sell a single share.
The reporting is precise. Your employer reports the spread in box 12 of Form W-2 with code V, and also includes it in boxes 1, 3 and 5, so it feeds wages, Social Security up to the wage base, and Medicare.[8] The practical trap is cash: withholding at the flat supplemental rate is often well short of what a large exercise actually costs a high earner, and the gap surfaces as an underpayment months later. Anyone balancing an exercise against other income that carries no withholding should read the quarterly estimated tax guide before the exercise date, not after it.
Why can Form 1099-B basis differ from your tax basis?
For options granted on or after January 1, 2014, Form 1099-B basis does not reflect compensation already included in income at grant or exercise. For older options, the reported basis may or may not reflect that compensation.[9] An RSU sale can present a similar mismatch if the broker reports a low basis or leaves it blank. Payroll and award records establish the compensation amount included in the employee’s tax basis.
Using a basis that excludes previously taxed compensation can overstate the gain. Form 8949 reconciles the reported basis with the tax basis when an adjustment is needed.[9] When a sale produces substantial investment income, a separate surtax can apply. See the net investment income tax guide.
When are RSUs taxed if vesting and settlement differ?
Vesting means the employee has satisfied the conditions to earn the award. Settlement is when the employer delivers the shares or cash. They often happen together. If shares are delivered later, ordinary federal income tax generally follows the transfer of the vested shares. Deferred awards can have separate payroll-tax timing rules.[10][12]
For vested shares delivered at settlement, the capital holding period generally starts upon acquisition. A sale within a year can produce a short-term gain or loss, depending on how the sale price compares with the basis. A sale to cover withholding close to settlement can produce a small gain or loss if the price has barely moved. Cash-settled units provide wages and leave the employee with no shares to sell.

How does a Section 83(b) election apply to RSUs and early-exercised ISOs?
An RSU grant is generally a promise of future payment, so the grant itself does not transfer property eligible for Section 83(b). A transfer of actual restricted stock can qualify for an election to recognize compensation in the transfer year. For the distinction, see the Section 83(b) election guide.[10][12][15]
When an employee early-exercises an ISO and receives restricted shares, the election can move the AMT inclusion to the stock transfer date. For regular income tax, a qualifying ISO exercise generally creates no taxable income. Early exercise and later sale therefore call for keeping the regular and AMT bases separate.[2][11]
What actually goes wrong on an equity compensation return?
- An applicable ISO exercise adjustment is omitted from the AMT calculation.[3]
- ISO shares are sold one clock short, and the spread at exercise is left as capital gain instead of wages.[5]
- A broker’s Form 1099-B basis that omits previously taxed wages overstates capital gain.[9]
- The regular basis and the AMT basis are tracked as one number, so the gain on a later sale is wrong under one of the two systems.[3]
- Withholding on a large exercise or vesting event is treated as final, and the balance surfaces as an underpayment at filing.
None of these are exotic. They are what happens when the grant documents, the payroll reporting and the brokerage statement get read separately instead of together, usually in April, usually by someone seeing them for the first time. Reconciling the three before an exercise or a sale is where the money is, and that is what our advisory solutions work looks like for equity holders. Partners, consultants and other high earners who hold awards alongside self employment income can start from our professional services tax help page.

Frequently asked questions
Is an incentive stock option taxed when I exercise it?
A qualifying incentive stock option exercise generally creates no regular taxable income. It can create an AMT adjustment when the stock becomes transferable or is no longer subject to a substantial risk of forfeiture. A disposition in the same tax year as exercise generally eliminates the separate AMT adjustment.
What income does exercising a non-qualified stock option create?
For a nonstatutory option with no readily determinable value at grant, nothing is taxed at grant, and at exercise you include the market value of the shares received less the amount you paid. That spread is ordinary wage income for the year of exercise. Your employer reports it in box 12 of Form W-2 with code V and also includes it in boxes 1, 3 and 5, so it is subject to income tax withholding, Social Security up to the wage base, and Medicare.
When do RSUs become taxable?
RSUs generally create ordinary wage income when settled in vested shares or cash. Settlement often coincides with vesting, but the award can provide for delivery later. If the employee receives vested shares, the capital holding period generally begins at acquisition. Later price changes determine the gain or loss at sale.
What is a disqualifying disposition of ISO shares?
It is a sale that misses the holding period test. That test runs on two clocks: the 1-year mark counted from the day the shares were transferred to you, and the 2-year mark counted from the grant date, whichever of the two ends later. On an arm’s-length sale at a gain, the ordinary income is the smaller of the actual gain or the difference between the share value at exercise and the option price. Any remaining gain is capital gain. On an arm’s-length sale at a loss there is generally no ordinary income and the whole result is a capital loss.
When will I receive Form 3921 for an ISO exercise?
The recipient statement is generally due January 31 after the year the shares are transferred. If that day is a weekend or legal holiday, the deadline moves to the next business day. For 2026 transfers, that is February 1, 2027.
Why is the cost basis on my Form 1099-B too low after an RSU or option sale?
For options granted on or after January 1, 2014, the reported basis excludes compensation already included in income. A broker can also show a low or blank basis on an RSU sale. The amount already taxed as wages generally belongs in the employee’s tax basis, so the broker’s figure can overstate the gain if used without reconciling it to the award and payroll records.
Sources
- Publication 525, Taxable and Nontaxable Income · Internal Revenue Service
- Topic no. 427, Stock options · Internal Revenue Service
- Publication 525, Taxable and Nontaxable Income · Internal Revenue Service
- Publication 525, Taxable and Nontaxable Income · Internal Revenue Service
- Publication 525, Taxable and Nontaxable Income · Internal Revenue Service
- Publication 525, Taxable and Nontaxable Income · Internal Revenue Service
- Topic no. 427, Stock options · Internal Revenue Service
- Publication 525, Taxable and Nontaxable Income · Internal Revenue Service
- Publication 525, Taxable and Nontaxable Income · Internal Revenue Service
- Publication 525, Taxable and Nontaxable Income · Internal Revenue Service
- Instructions for Form 6251, Alternative Minimum Tax for Individuals · Internal Revenue Service
- Publication 525, Taxable and Nontaxable Income · Internal Revenue Service
- Publication 1099, General Instructions for Certain Information Returns · Internal Revenue Service
- Publication 1099, General Instructions for Certain Information Returns · Internal Revenue Service
- Publication 525, Taxable and Nontaxable Income · Internal Revenue Service
Continue reading

Section 1045 QSBS Rollover: 60-Day Rule, Basis, and Section 1202
Section 1045 lets eligible sellers defer QSBS capital gain by buying qualified replacement shares in the 60-day period beginning on the sale date. Compare basis and the Section 1202 exclusion.

QSEHRA vs. ICHRA: 2026 and 2027 Limits and Small-Business Rules
QSEHRA and ICHRA both reimburse eligible health costs. The comparison turns on employer size, how the benefit coordinates with other health coverage and what happens to an employee’s Marketplace tax credit.

SECURE 2.0 Auto-Enrollment: Which New 401(k) Plans Must Enroll Employees
Section 414A already applies to certain 401(k) and 403(b) plans. Final IRS regulations clarify which eligible employees must be enrolled, when business exceptions end, and how default contributions increase.
About the author

Founder & Principal · Enrolled Agent (EA)
Joanny Ibarbia is an Enrolled Agent with unlimited rights to represent taxpayers before the IRS, and a Certifying Acceptance Agent for ITIN applications. He leads the bilingual tax and accounting practice at Top Pro Accounting.
- EA
- CAA
- Harvard Certified
- QuickBooks ProAdvisor
Image credits
- Photo by AlphaTradeZone Pexels
- Photo by Yan Krukau Pexels
- Photo by Leeloo The First Pexels
- Photo by Yan Krukau Pexels
- Photo by Nataliya Vaitkevich Pexels

